2.4万円で売った仮面が競売で6.6億円、元所有者の売却取り消し請求棄却 仏

Mask sold for 24,000 yen sold at auction for 660 million yen, former owner’s request to cancel sale rejected France

Mask sold for 24,000 yen sold at auction for 660 million yen, former owner’s request to cancel sale rejected France
フランスの裁判所は19日、高齢夫婦が150ユーロ(約2万4000円)で骨董(こっとう)商に売却したアフリカの仮面が、競売で420万ユーロ(約6億6000万円)で落札されたため売却の取り消しを求めていた裁判で、夫婦の軽率さが原因だとして訴えを退けた

A French court ruled on the 19th that an African mask sold by an elderly couple to an antique dealer for 150 euros (approximately 24,000 yen) was sold at auction for 4.2 million euros (approximately 660 million yen). In a lawsuit seeking to cancel the sale, the lawsuit was dismissed, citing the couple’s imprudence.

A French court ruled on the 19th that an African mask sold by an elderly couple to an antique dealer for 150 euros (approximately 24,000 yen) was sold at auction for 4.2 million euros (approximately 660 million yen). In a lawsuit seeking to cancel the sale, the lawsuit was dismissed, citing the couple’s imprudence.
80代の夫婦は2021年9月、南仏の別宅に保管されていた仮面を処分するため、アフリカで作られたやりや割礼用のナイフなどと共に売却した

In September 2021, a couple in their 80s sold the masks, which had been stored in a separate house in the south of France, along with spears and circumcision knives made in Africa.

In September 2021, a couple in their 80s sold the masks, which had been stored in a separate house in the south of France, along with spears and circumcision knives made in Africa.
これらはアフリカで総督を務めていた先祖が所有していた物で、さほど価値はないと考えていた

These were owned by an ancestor who served as a governor in Africa, and were not considered to be of much value.

These were owned by an ancestor who served as a governor in Africa, and were not considered to be of much value.
夫婦は仮面を150ユーロで売却した

The couple sold the mask for 150 euros.

The couple sold the mask for 150 euros.
しかし、2022年3月に南仏モンペリエ (Montpellier)で行われた競売では420万ユーロで落札された

However, it was sold for 4.2 million euros at an auction in Montpellier, southern France, in March 2022.

However, it was sold for 4.2 million euros at an auction in Montpellier, southern France, in March 2022.
落札者の身元は明らかになっていない

The identity of the winning bidder has not been revealed.

The identity of the winning bidder has not been revealed.
競売会社は、仮面は「19世紀にガボンの少数民族ファン(Fang)の秘密結社が儀式で使っていた極めて希少なもの」で、同様の物は10個ほどしか現存していないとしている

The auction house says the mask is ”an extremely rare item that was used in rituals by the Fang ethnic group in Gabon in the 19th century,” and that there are only about 10 similar items in existence.

The auction house says the mask is ”an extremely rare item that was used in rituals by the Fang ethnic group in Gabon in the 19th century,” and that there are only about 10 similar items in existence.
競売のことを知った夫婦は直ちに、「鑑定ミス」があったとして150ユーロでの売却の取り消しを求めて訴えた

When the couple found out about the auction, they immediately sued to have the sale canceled for 150 euros, alleging that there had been an ”error in appraisal.”

When the couple found out about the auction, they immediately sued to have the sale canceled for 150 euros, alleging that there had been an ”error in appraisal.”
また、仮面を買った骨董商は最初から「仮面の真の価値に気付いていた」と主張した

Additionally, the antique dealer who bought the mask claimed that he was ``aware of the mask’s true value’’ from the beginning.

Additionally, the antique dealer who bought the mask claimed that he was ``aware of the mask’s true value’’ from the beginning.
だが裁判所は、夫婦は売却前に仮面の評価額を知るための努力を一切しなかったと指摘

However, the court pointed out that the couple made no effort to find out the appraised value of the mask before selling it.

However, the court pointed out that the couple made no effort to find out the appraised value of the mask before selling it.
夫婦の「言い訳できない怠慢と軽率さ」が原因だとの判断を下した

The judge ruled that the couple’s ”inexcusable negligence and thoughtlessness” was the cause.

The judge ruled that the couple’s ”inexcusable negligence and thoughtlessness” was the cause.
また、骨董商自身もアフリカ美術の専門家ではなく、夫婦を欺いた訳ではないとしている

Additionally, the antique dealer himself is not an expert on African art, and says he did not deceive the couple.

Additionally, the antique dealer himself is not an expert on African art, and says he did not deceive the couple.
骨董商は、競売の開始価格と同じ30万ユーロ(約4700万円)を示談金として提示したが、夫婦の子どもらが訴訟を優先するとして、拒否していた

The antique dealer offered 300,000 euros (approximately 47 million yen), the same as the starting price of the auction, as a settlement sum, but the couple’s children refused, saying they would prioritize litigation.

The antique dealer offered 300,000 euros (approximately 47 million yen), the same as the starting price of the auction, as a settlement sum, but the couple’s children refused, saying they would prioritize litigation.
夫婦の代理人弁護士は、控訴を検討していると話した

A lawyer representing the couple said they are considering an appeal.

A lawyer representing the couple said they are considering an appeal.
仮面をめぐっては、ガボン政府も競売の取り消しと仮面の返還を求め訴えていたが、裁判所はこの訴えも退けた

Regarding the masks, the Gabonese government also sued to cancel the auction and return the masks, but the court also rejected this lawsuit.

Regarding the masks, the Gabonese government also sued to cancel the auction and return the masks, but the court also rejected this lawsuit.